| Friday, May 4 |
Saturday, May 5 |
| Game 1: #3 Allegheny 5, #2 Wittenberg 3 (8) |
Game 5: Denison 5, Hiram 2 |
| Game 2: #1 Denison 7, #4 Hiram 6 (11) |
Game 6: Denison 4, Allegheny 1 |
| Game 3: Allegheny 2, Denison 0 |
Game 7: Allegheny 2, Denison 0 |
| Game 4: Hiram 5, Wittenberg 1 |
|