| 2025 CSCAA Scholar All-America Individuals (Men) |
| Denison |
| Andre Beduschi - Global Commerce |
| Ben Bevill - Data Analytics |
| Christian McIntire - Data Analytics |
| Christian Narcelles - Biochemistry |
| Elijah Venos - Psychology |
| Gavin Jones - Economics & Communication |
| George Goins - Financial Economics |
| Jack Hill - Economics |
| Max Soja - Health, Exercise, & Sports Studies |
| Liam Nelson - Health, Exercise, & Sports Studies |
| Lucas Conrads - Health, Exercise, & Sports Studies |
| Luke Swiggett - Global Commerce & Data Analytics |
| Nick Fogle - Psychology |
| Nick Hensel - Financial Economics |
| Patrick Daly - Financial Economics |
| Tyler Distenfeld - Biology |
| Ben Campbell - Economics (2nd Team) |
| Josh Thomas - Politics and Public Affairs & Journalism (2nd Team) |
| Kenyon |
| Ethan Manske - Environmental Studies |
| Kirill Sidorko - Economics |
| Neil Abrahamson - Chemistry |
| Noel Tumbasz - Political Science |
| Peter Dunson - Mathematics |
| Roman Savage - Political Science |
| Spencer Stluka - Chemistry |
| James Lackner - Biochemistry (2nd Team) |
| Owen Peterson - Physics (2nd Team) |
| 2025 CSCAA Scholar All-America Individuals (Women) |
| Denison |
| Amber Croonquist - Biology |
| Avery Vogen - Biology |
| Drue Thielking - Biology |
| Emily Harris - Financial Economics |
| Emma Pritchett - Journalism |
| Grace Kadlecik - Health, Exercise, & Sports Studies |
| Jasmine Park - Biology |
| Kerstyn Johnson - Theater and Health, Exercise, & Sports Studies |
| Maja Palmroos - Data Analytics |
| Phoebe Ferguson - Health, Exercise, & Sports Studies |
| Quinn Brown - Psychology |
| Riley Tofflemire - Economics |
| Taryn Wisner - Psychology |
| Lu Si Minnich - Financial Economics (2nd Team) |
| Maddie Schaefer - History and Politics & Public Affairs (2nd Team) |
| DePauw |
| Anya Melson - Neuroscience |
| Caroline Stowe - Kinesiology (2nd Team) |
| Cora Gilbert - Kinesiology (2nd Team) |
| Kenyon |
| Amelia Stevenson - Molecular Biology |
| Ashlyn Widmer - Biology |
| Bengisu Caymaz - Neuroscience |
| Ceyda Yazici - Biochemistry |
| Gabby Wei - Sociology |
| Gwen Eisenbeis - Mathematics |
| Jennah Fadely - Psychology |
| Jordan Herrera - Neuroscience |
| Kate Bogan - Psychology |
| Lisa Torrecillas-Jouault - Political Science |
| Molly Haag - Mathematics |
| Nora Lee Brown - Neuroscience |
| Sofia Giordano - Political Science |
| Sydney Geboy - Psychology |
| Lucy Cassell-Kelley - Biochemistry (2nd Team) |
| Nadia Milovich - Economics (2nd Team) |
| Naomi Kennel - Biology (2nd Team) |
| Tuva Siegel - Creative Writing (2nd Team) |
| Wooster |
| Ollie Bream - Communication Sciences and Disorders (2nd Team) |